This movie is crazy…but crazy good! I have never watched a
David Lynch movie, and I am kind of glad this one was the first one. I knew
that Lynch’s auteur style is more on the non-mainstream style, and I definitely
saw that. I had to go into a surrealist mindset to sort of understand this
film. This film is very “dream-like” and not everything I watch I will fully
understand. This may be frustrating for some of the audience members, but it is
not really for me. It wasn’t until the reading; I sort of understood/explored
the possible meanings behind this film.
I really feel that this film takes the perspective
of the dreamer being Hollywood. Dreams are “learned habits of the mind” that
usually “fail to support our needs, but often loom as frightening adversaries in
our struggle to cope” (Nochimson). This dream we see reveals a sad, horrific,
confusing, grotesque results, such as Betty/Diane’s suicide (Nochimson). Usually
the Hollywood we see isn’t always happy ending. This dream seems mechanical, a “mass-market
machine that feeds on genuine, not imaginary, creative impulses and turns them
into waste products” (Nochimson). Life and death. Lynch also plays on those
usual Hollywood stereotypes, but then twists them to the unordinary, not seen
personas. Hence the artificial acting (at first). We root for Betty and her
success, but as soon as she has everything, she loses everything in one moment.
A missed opportunity of meeting with Adam, the famous Hollywood director, which
later results to a “butterfly effect”. It was from the moment on that things
started going downhill.
This dream we are watching is created by a culture
industry, Hollywood, which has a lot of power and control. It is filled with
life and death, defeat and hope…we see all of that in various films, especially
the classic ones (Nochimson). There are
lots of illusion, and void within this dream-like film, especially when Betty
and Rita go to Club Silencio. We hear the band, the singing, but there is
nothing there. The film ends with Club Silencio, with a woman saying “Silencio”
(which means silence in Spanish). This phrase resonates on the audience, hence
the long black screen before the credits…”full of signs of both empty illusion
and fullness of possibility” (Nochimson). I agree with the reading, this brings
a questionable future not for the characters, but for Hollywood/popular culture
(Nochimson). But also for us. Possibilities can come out of this dark void, but
also death.
Interesting thoughts! Love reading your blog. What about the Silencio Club? In the dream logic of Diane's imaginings I think that it's part of the glamor of Hollywood, and the out-of-body existence of many actors, and perhaps the ultimate emptiness of the reality that films purport to give us. For me, it highlights the sort of "dark underbelly" of the supposed glamorous "world" of Hollywood. Anyone who has ever been to Hollywood (the city) knows it's a crap-hole. Furthermore, the Hollywood film industry is mostly full of messed up people who live unhappy lives.
ReplyDeleteI am hooked on Lynch now. I love that he took these stock characters and at the best moments, flipped their worlds upside down. Club Silencio might have been my favorite part. Silence Can be deafening. Like you said it's full of possibilities and the illusions Of hearing the music while the musician isn't playing or the singer isn't singing definitely emphasizes the dream like atmosphere. If nothing else isn't built on possibilities, dreams are, no matter how horrifying.
ReplyDeleteThis was also my first Lynch movie as well and at first I have to agree that it was crazy. Then it's like something draws you in and you just get addicted to what is going on with these characters. I have to admit that Silencio had one of my favorite scenes seeing the women perform was so moving and when she collapsed her voice didn't stop as her human form went silent but the prerecorded voice kept going. This may be what Diane is experiencing her life had a plan, but then she collapsed(Camilla left her) and is devastated that life is still going on with out her This was definetly my favorite movie so far.
ReplyDeleteThe last line of the movie sort of summarized what you're saying. Silencio! gotta have quiet to dream, and nobody in Diane's position would have desired awakening from her nightmare of a life. And yes it was definitely a better move by Lynch starting off all cliche Hollywood and then reverse it, and not the other way around.
ReplyDeleteReally good summary, and I like how you get to the heart of the thing, and also allow it to have its own mystery. Also, good discussion here.
ReplyDelete